A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Stumper

A winning hit, a missing touch, and a pennant race

1908 Merkle game: an unfinished afternoon in a pennant race

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Stumper

1908 Merkle game: an unfinished afternoon in a pennant race

The 1908 Merkle game ended with a hit, a crowd on the field, and a ruling that took away New York's apparent winning run. On September 23, the Giants and Chicago Cubs were tied at the Polo Grounds when Fred Merkle stopped short of second base. Umpire Hank O'Day called him out on a force play. The contest remained a tie, leaving a disputed afternoon unfinished in the middle of a three-team pennant race.

Chicago had scored on Joe Tinker's fifth-inning home run against Christy Mathewson. New York answered in the sixth when Mike Donlin singled home Buck Herzog. Neither club scored again before the Giants came to bat in the ninth. Art Devlin singled, then was forced at second on Moose McCormick's grounder. McCormick remained at first with two outs when Merkle came to the plate.

Merkle singled to right, sending McCormick to third. Al Bridwell followed with a hit through the middle, and McCormick crossed home. In his 1912 memoir, Pitching in a Pinch, Mathewson recalled that the familiar custom of treating such a run as the end of the game had shaped Merkle's response. Merkle headed for the clubhouse while Chicago's Johnny Evers and Tinker pursued a force-out claim at second. Mathewson believed another Giant in the same position would have behaved similarly.

The ball's journey through the crowd became a separate controversy. Trey Strecker's SABR biography draws on Merkle's affidavit: Merkle said he turned toward the clubhouse about 15 feet short of second, then returned to the base during the argument. Norm King's SABR reconstruction treats the ball's retrieval as uncertain because the descriptions differ. Evers eventually touched second with a ball and appealed. O'Day's force-out ruling erased the run; the crowd and gathering darkness prevented further play.

Mathewson remembered the Giants initially laughing when they heard the decision in the clubhouse. They did not immediately regard the appeal as a threat to their season. His later recollection followed the controversy as it became increasingly serious, with the Cubs demanding recognition of the ruling and the Giants believing they had already earned the victory. The 1908 Merkle game remained unresolved while the clubs continued their schedules, and Pittsburgh remained part of the championship race.

Another series altered the shape of the chase. Mathewson described Philadelphia pitcher Coveleski beating the Giants three times, the last game by a narrow margin. New York returned home on Saturday night with three Boston games remaining. Chicago still had to face Pittsburgh; in Mathewson's recollection, that Sunday fixture was Pittsburgh's final opportunity to capture the pennant before a Giants–Cubs replay became necessary.

The Giants' pitcher also described an unusual Sunday gathering at the Polo Grounds. Spectators watched an electric scoreboard report Chicago's game against Pittsburgh. New York needed the Cubs to win to preserve its own opportunity, so a Giants crowd cheered for Chicago. The Cubs won, eliminating Pittsburgh. New York then won three games against Boston, creating the tie that required the September contest to be played again. Mathewson estimated the Sunday scoreboard crowd at 10,000.

Before the replay, Mathewson recalled a divided clubhouse. Some players resisted competing for a championship they thought had already been settled. A committee including Mathewson, Devlin, Roger Bresnahan, Donlin, and Fred Tenney consulted club president John T. Brush. According to Mathewson, Brush left the decision with the players while expressing confidence that they would continue the contest. The delegation agreed to play. Brush then promised the team a $10,000 bonus regardless of the result.

The replay took place on October 8. Donna L. Halper's SABR research follows the Cubs' nearly 18-hour train journey on the Twentieth Century Limited and the crowds gathering outside the Polo Grounds early that morning. New York took a first-inning lead, but Chicago manager Frank Chance replaced starter Jack Pfiester with Mordecai Brown before the inning ended. Brown finished the game, allowing the Giants only one further run over 8 1/3 innings of relief.

Chicago scored all four of its runs in the third inning. Tinker tripled, Johnny Kling singled him home, and later doubles by Frank Schulte and Chance completed the rally. The Cubs won 4-2 and secured the National League pennant. Mathewson's own account accepted responsibility for his pitching in the replay. He also recalled manager John McGraw consistently defending Merkle during the intervening weeks, when public criticism had concentrated on the young first baseman.

The 1908 Merkle game was followed by a long playing career. Strecker records that Merkle became New York's regular first baseman in 1910, batting .292 with 70 runs batted in. In 1912 he reached .309. New York traded him to Brooklyn in August 1916, and the Robins sold him to Chicago for $3,500 in 1917. He spent three seasons in the Cubs' starting lineup and appeared in the 1918 World Series.

The Question

Which base did Fred Merkle fail to touch during the disputed Giants–Cubs finish on September 23, 1908?

Show the answer

The Answer

Second base. Hank O'Day called Merkle out on a force play, erasing the apparent winning run and leaving a tie that was later replayed.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Sport Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.