Yogi Berra: the mitt, the final out and Larsen’s perfect game
Yogi Berra's catcher's mitt is a surviving working object from Don Larsen's perfect game on October 8, 1956. The National Baseball Hall of Fame identifies it as the mitt Berra used while receiving the Yankees pitcher's Game 5 performance against Brooklyn. It also preserves a ball used that day, tickets and photographs. The familiar celebration followed 97 pitches and a 2-0 New York victory. Before Berra could jump into Larsen's arms, the battery had to complete a game in which no Dodger reached base.
The pitching matchup had not promised an easy afternoon. Sal Maglie started for Brooklyn, and neither club collected a hit through three innings. Larsen, meanwhile, had lasted into only the second inning of Game 2 three days earlier. SABR historian Charles F. Faber's reconstruction distinguishes that recent failure from the sharp control Larsen found in Game 5. He had also developed a delivery without a windup near the end of the regular season. Berra was receiving a pitcher whose immediate postseason experience offered little reassurance.
The defense intervened early. In the second inning Jackie Robinson hit a hard ball that glanced off third baseman Andy Carey's glove toward shortstop Gil McDougald, who threw him out. In the fifth, Gil Hodges drove to deep left-center, where Mickey Mantle ran the ball down. Sandy Amoros then sent a ball into the right-field stands, but it curled foul before he grounded out. These plays, described in Faber's reconstruction, show why the absence of hits did not mean an absence of threatening contact.
Mantle also changed the scoreboard. His fourth-inning home run put the Yankees ahead, and another run followed in the sixth. Larsen reached a three-ball count against only one batter. The Hall's preserved game details therefore combine very few deep counts with outs that required fielders to react. For Yogi Berra, the job behind the plate continued through both kinds of pitching result: receiving an untouched pitch and staying ready while a batted ball put the defense into motion. In the memoir recollection Faber cites, Larsen trusted his catcher and seldom shook off his signals during the game.
The ninth began with Carl Furillo flying to right and Roy Campanella grounding to second. Walter Alston then used Dale Mitchell as a pinch-hitter for Maglie. Larsen struck Mitchell out, completing the perfect game, and Berra sprang toward the mound. The Hall records that Mitchell struck out only once in 29 career World Series at-bats. The last confrontation ended with a rare result for the hitter as well as an exceptional result for the pitcher and catcher.
Berra had already learned his position through a specific coaching relationship. His museum's biography credits Bill Dickey, who returned to the Yankees as a coach in 1949, with teaching him catching's techniques and nuances. Both wore number 8. The same institutional history records Berra catching Allie Reynolds's two no-hitters in 1951 and once handling 148 straight games without a catching error. Those are directly relevant credentials for the man receiving Larsen, rather than an explanation based only on his exuberance after the final pitch.
Another primary record survives from a much less privileged vantage point. Sports Illustrated published color slides from an unidentified spectator seated far from home plate. Keith Olbermann, who acquired the slides, described their provenance in 2016: the photographer's widow brought them to a Florida memorabilia dealer in 1999 along with her husband's ticket stub and program. The photographer had spent much of his film before play began. His pictures did not capture the final pitch or Yogi Berra's leap.
They did preserve a scoreboard showing Brooklyn with no runs, hits or errors and New York with two runs, five hits and no errors. Other slides showed Mantle in center field, pregame Dodgers and the stadium's monuments. The figures on the scoreboard document the result independently of the famous celebration image. Olbermann's discussion of the removed batter's-eye backdrop is a later interpretation of the stadium conditions. The pictures preserve a spectator's view; explanations of why Larsen succeeded go beyond their visible numerical record.
The Yogi Berra Museum's 70th-anniversary exhibition places his game-used 1956 mitt beside other memorabilia, including original baseball cards and a handwritten scorecard from a 1999 perfect game. The latter occurred on Yogi Berra Day, giving the museum a second event to set beside the first. A scorecard belongs to the documentation of play, while the mitt belonged to its execution. The two kinds of object preserve different work: marking what happened and receiving the pitches as it happened. In the 1956 pairing, Berra's mitt fixes the catcher firmly within a performance so often named for Larsen alone.
- Craig Muder, National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Don Larsen defined World Series perfection: game-used Berra mitt, baseball, ticket and game details — baseballhall.org
- Charles F. Faber, SABR Games Project, October 8, 1956: Don Larsen throws a perfect game in the World Series — sabr.org
- Yogi Berra Museum and Learning Center, Biography: Bill Dickey and Berra’s catching experience — yogiberramuseum.org
- Keith Olbermann, Sports Illustrated, Picture Perfect, October 4, 2016: spectator’s original color slides and provenance — www.si.com
- Yogi Berra Museum and Learning Center, If the World Were Perfect: 70th-anniversary exhibition and artifact descriptions — yogiberramuseum.org