Chuck Howley and the two sides of a 16-13 Super Bowl
Chuck Howley intercepted two passes and forced a fumble in Super Bowl V, then finished on the losing side of a 16-13 score. The Pro Football Hall of Fame identifies the Dallas linebacker as the game's Most Valuable Player and the only recipient of that award from a defeated team. Baltimore won the championship in Miami on January 17, 1971. The individual honor and the team result belonged to different defenses: Howley took the ball away for Dallas, while the Colts' late interceptions supplied the chances that decided the score.
The Hall's discussion of Super Bowl V records Dallas with one touchdown, one successful extra point and two field goals. Those scores total 13 points: six from the touchdown, one from the conversion and six from the kicks. Baltimore had two touchdowns, one successful extra point and one field goal. Its 16 points came from a different balance of scoring plays, with O'Brien's final field goal supplying the winning margin. The Associated Press identifies Dallas's touchdown as Craig Morton's seven-yard pass to Duane Thomas before halftime. Dallas's offense did not add another score in the second half.
The Mackey touchdown was hardly an ordinary completion. The Associated Press's later reconstruction describes Unitas's throw touching receiver Eddie Hinton's fingertips and Dallas defensive back Mel Renfro before reaching Mackey. A ball intended for one receiver became a long scoring play for another. That sequence brought Baltimore back into a game Dallas had led through two field goals. It also illustrates the difficulty of reducing the afternoon to the performances of the quarterbacks: a deflection could change both possession and field position without a cleanly executed passing play.
Chuck Howley's takeaways occurred amid mistakes by both offenses. The AP summary records three interceptions thrown by each team and a lost fumble by Dallas. Baltimore also repeatedly put the ball on the ground. In the fourth quarter, Rick Volk intercepted Morton to set up the touchdown that tied the game. Tom Nowatzke supplied the scoring run. The Cowboys had carried a 13-6 advantage into the second half, but they added no more points. An excellent defensive performance by one Dallas player could not replace the scoring opportunities the offense surrendered.
The decisive turnover put another linebacker at the center of events. Mike Curtis described his interception to Don Banks during a 2015 interview for Sports Illustrated. Curtis remembered the ball coming off Dan Reeves's hands while he stood behind the intended receiver. His concern had been preventing a completion; suddenly he was carrying the ball himself. He emphasized protecting possession during the return and avoiding unnecessary contact. This was Curtis recalling his own action decades later, a participant's explanation of how a defensive assignment became Baltimore's final scoring opportunity.
Curtis returned the interception 13 yards to the Dallas 28. Baltimore then gained three yards on two running plays before calling on Jim O'Brien. The kicker had already missed a 52-yard field goal, and Dallas had blocked his earlier extra point. His final attempt came from 32 yards and broke the 13-13 tie with five seconds remaining. Chuck Howley's MVP selection did not reverse the effect of Curtis's interception or O'Brien's kick. The Colts had converted a late possession into the three points separating the teams at the finish.
The Hall's statistical register gives Chuck Howley's interceptions another scale. Across 14 regular-season games in 1970, it lists two interceptions and 18 return yards. He matched that interception count in the championship game alone. His highest regular-season interception total had been six in 1968, with 115 return yards. In 1971 he would intercept five passes and return them for 122 yards. The Super Bowl MVP selection recognized a linebacker whose regular work already included taking passes away from the opposing offense.
Chuck Howley's next Super Bowl ended differently. Dallas beat Miami 24-3 the following season, with Howley intercepting a pass and recovering a fumble. The Hall credits the Cowboys' defense with holding the Dolphins to 185 total yards. Those contributions paired familiar defensive work with a team championship. His 1971 MVP performance had come after five consecutive first-team All-Pro seasons from 1966 through 1970, so the award recognized an established outside linebacker. The loss to Baltimore and victory over Miami were consecutive championship appearances with defensive takeaways in each.
A football from that second appearance entered the Hall's Class of 2023 exhibit, alongside Chuck Howley's Dallas Ring of Honor trophy. The museum's exhibit announcement identifies the ball specifically with Super Bowl VI and the 24-3 victory. It should therefore be associated with the Miami game, rather than with his MVP award against Baltimore. The objects came from personal memorabilia selected by the inductees or their families. For Howley, the displayed football preserves the championship that followed the exceptional individual honor earned during a defeat.
- Pro Football Hall of Fame, Chuck Howley: player record and championship performances — www.profootballhof.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame, Changing the Rules archived: Super Bowl V scoring totals and point values — www.profootballhof.com
- Associated Press, SB 5: Unitas and Colts win turnover-filled game over Cowboys, January 20, 2016, Sports Illustrated — www.si.com
- Don Banks, Super Bowl Game-Changers: Mike Curtis interview, January 21, 2015, Sports Illustrated — www.si.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame, Class of 2023 featured exhibit: Howley football and Ring of Honor trophy, June 9, 2023 — www.profootballhof.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame, Hall of Famers in the Super Bowl: Super Bowls V and VI dates and results — www.profootballhof.com