Johnny Vander Meer and the two hitless starts of 1938
Johnny Vander Meer pitched two consecutive major-league no-hitters for the Cincinnati Reds in June 1938. On June 11, he beat the Boston Bees 3–0 at Crosley Field. Four days later, he beat the Brooklyn Dodgers 6–0 at Ebbets Field. The National Baseball Hall of Fame preserves a baseball from the first game and a ticket stub from the second, material traces of two starts that made the young pitcher nationally famous.
The Reds had entered 1938 after 11 consecutive losing seasons. In Gregory H. Wolf's reconstruction for the Society for American Baseball Research, manager Bill McKechnie's arrival helped turn them into a competitive club. Cincinnati stood 23–20 before the Boston game, in third place in the National League. Vander Meer was 23 and had experienced an uneven major-league debut in 1937. He finished that earlier major-league campaign 3–5 and spent part of it back with Syracuse in the minors. By June 1938, however, he had won three straight starts.
Against Boston, Vander Meer retired the first nine batters. Center fielder Harry Craft contributed an important catch on the terrace in deep center, taking an extra-base hit away from Gil English. A later drive by Vince DiMaggio deflected from the pitcher toward third baseman Lew Riggs, who completed the out at first. Catcher Ernie Lombardi supplied both defensive help and a two-run home run in the sixth inning. Vander Meer struck out four, walked three, and faced 28 batters. His ninth inning consisted of three successive pinch-hitters, all retired, and the game ended after 1 hour and 45 minutes.
The Brooklyn start combined the pitching story with a separate ballpark milestone. Ebbets Field was staging its first major-league night game. Wolf's reconstruction records a crowd of 38,748 and the activation of the new lights at 8:35 p.m. Vander Meer's parents attended, along with a group of 500 supporters from his New Jersey hometown. The opening festivities delayed the first pitch until 9:45 p.m. Cincinnati's offense then supplied an early lead, including a home run by Frank McCormick during a four-run third inning.
The finish was much less orderly than the score. In the ninth, Vander Meer recorded one out and then walked Babe Phelps, Cookie Lavagetto, and Dolph Camilli. McKechnie visited the mound but left him in the game. Riggs fielded Ernie Koy's grounder and threw home for a force out. Leo Durocher then hit a foul ball down the right-field line before lifting the decisive fly to Craft in center. Vander Meer finished with eight walks and seven strikeouts. Brooklyn had put runners aboard repeatedly, but none of its batters had recorded a hit.
The Hall of Fame's Bill Francis follows the sequence into the next start, against Boston on June 19. Debs Garms singled in the fourth inning, ending the run of hitless pitching. Cincinnati nevertheless won 14–1, with Vander Meer pitching the complete game. He later started the 1938 All-Star Game at Crosley Field, worked three scoreless innings, and received the victory in the National League's 4–1 win. His season finished at 15–10. The two June no-hitters were part of an eight-game winning streak during that campaign.
Another document in Cooperstown records the response beyond baseball. A typed letter dated June 17, 1938, congratulated Johnny Vander Meer on both performances. Its sender was FBI director J. Edgar Hoover. In Francis's account of the museum's copy, Hoover explained that he had followed the games through a Miami newspaper's sports pages. He described baseball as a favorite sport, mentioned the competing demands of his official work, and included news of the FBI's own baseball team in Washington. The letter ended with his hope of seeing a third no-hitter that season. The museum also preserves the envelope associated with the correspondence.
A further no-hitter arrived in a different league and a different decade. Ernest J. Green's Baseball Research Journal study reconstructs Johnny Vander Meer's July 15, 1952, start for Tulsa against Beaumont in the Texas League. Cincinnati had acquired him in 1935, and his final major-league season came with Cleveland in 1951. Only 335 spectators attended the game at Stuart Stadium. Shortstop Alex Grammas preserved the hitless performance with a difficult eighth-inning play, and right fielder Francis Brown caught Marshall Carlson's fly for the final out. Beaumont's manager was Harry Craft, the same center fielder who had caught the last ball in Brooklyn in 1938. In his next start, on July 22, the possibility of another consecutive no-hitter lasted one inning. Vander Meer finished the Tulsa season with an 11–10 record, a 2.31 earned-run average, and 96 strikeouts.
- Bill Francis, National Baseball Hall of Fame: Make His a Double — baseballhall.org
- Gregory H. Wolf, SABR: June 11, 1938: Reds’ Johnny Vander Meer tosses first no-hitter — sabr.org
- Gregory H. Wolf, SABR: June 15, 1938: Johnny Vander Meer tosses second straight no-hitter in historic night game at Ebbets Field — sabr.org
- Bill Francis, National Baseball Hall of Fame: #Shortstops: FBI files in Cooperstown — baseballhall.org
- Ernest J. Green, Baseball Research Journal: Johnny Vander Meer’s Third No-Hitter — sabr.org