A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Stumper

Which jersey would you hand the emergency goalie?

David Ayres and His Emergency Win for Carolina

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Stumper

David Ayres and His Emergency Win for Carolina

On February 22, 2020, David Ayres entered an NHL game at Scotiabank Arena in Toronto wearing the role of an emergency goalie for the visiting Carolina Hurricanes. Both Carolina goalies, James Reimer and Petr Mrazek, had left with injuries. The Hurricanes needed someone to finish the game, and the 42-year-old Ayres became their replacement. He made eight saves over the final 28 minutes and 41 seconds as Carolina defeated the Toronto Maple Leafs 6-3. His NHL debut ended in victory for the visiting team, even though much of his hockey experience had come through working with Toronto players.

Ayres was a maintenance operations manager at the Mattamy facility, formerly Maple Leaf Gardens. But he also had substantial experience facing professional players in practice. He had spent eight years as a practice goalie with the Toronto Marlies of the American Hockey League and three with the Maple Leafs. Those sessions gave him a continuing place around professional hockey without an appearance in an NHL or AHL game. David Ayres arrived in Carolina's crease as someone familiar with stopping shots, though new to this level of competition.

The transition was difficult at first. Ayres entered during the second period and felt nervous as Toronto scored twice. His new teammates helped him settle. Forward Erik Haula approached him with encouragement, telling him to enjoy the experience and relieving the pressure to treat every possible goal as a disaster. Ayres later said that reassurance calmed him. After the early goals, he stopped the next eight shots he faced. Carolina's players continued working toward the win, and coach Rod Brind'Amour later spoke about their determination to keep competing. The team turned an abrupt loss of both regular goaltenders into a shared effort around its emergency replacement.

The finish brought recognition beyond the final score. David Ayres became the first emergency backup goalie to win an NHL game and the oldest goalie to win a regular-season debut. He was named the game's first star, the top selection among the three players honored at its conclusion. His Carolina teammates celebrated with a shower from their water bottles, surprising him before he reached an ordinary shower. He described the experience as a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. His wife Sarah shared her excitement publicly, celebrating the fulfillment of his dream and the intensity of a night that had left her nearly without a voice.

The days afterward carried him into television studios and a new hockey city. On Monday, Ayres appeared on Today, Ellen and The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. On Tuesday, Carolina honored him in Raleigh before its home game against the Dallas Stars. He sounded the pregame siren at PNC Arena and encountered people who stopped him to say how much they had enjoyed his story. What began as an urgent substitution had become a public celebration. The attention continued while he traveled, with media appearances and personal greetings filling a week he had scarcely had time to absorb.

His stick joined the Hockey Hall of Fame in Toronto on February 28. The visit to Brookfield Place on Yonge Street was his first trip to the Hall's home since 1993, and this time a ceremony honored his own contribution. Seeing equipment from one appearance displayed near the achievements of great players felt extraordinary to him. Sarah had visited the museum before they met and found it difficult to comprehend seeing her husband's stick in a case. David Ayres and his wife had previously imagined that an emergency appearance might lead to a few interviews. The scale of the response had gone far beyond those expectations.

Ayres used the attention to discuss organ donation. In 2004, his mother Mary had donated a kidney for his transplant, and he had feared he would never play hockey again. After the Carolina appearance, he planned speaking engagements to share his experience with other transplant recipients and promote awareness. Invitations included a Saskatoon hockey game and events connected with a Buffalo hospital and kidney foundations in Houston and North Carolina. Hurricanes general manager Don Waddell welcomed the opportunity to support those causes. The unexpected hockey spotlight offered Ayres a way to connect his playing experience with a much earlier turning point in his life.

A year later, people were still contacting him almost daily, whether in stores, interviews, podcasts or social media. At his home in Bowmanville, Ontario, David Ayres arranged a locker behind the couch where he watched Hurricanes games. It held equipment from the Toronto appearance and a white jersey signed by Carolina fans. Pandemic restrictions prevented him from traveling to Raleigh for the anniversary, so he taped a message thanking supporters. The club planned to honor the occasion without him in the building. His anniversary schedule also included a podcast from Sweden and an interview with NBCSN, extending the conversations about his appearance across another busy day.

The Question

When emergency goalie David Ayres won his NHL debut in Toronto in 2020, which team was he playing for?

Show the answer

The Answer

Carolina Hurricanes. Ayres had served as a practice goalie for Toronto teams, but he entered the game for visiting Carolina. The Hurricanes won 6-3 after both of their regular goalies were injured.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Sport Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.