Akron Pros and the championship awarded at a meeting
The Akron Pros became the first champions of the American Professional Football Association after an undefeated 1920 season. Their recorded season mark was eight wins, no losses, and three ties. The title was awarded at a meeting on April 30, 1921, rather than in a championship game. The association subsequently became the National Football League, making Akron's championship the first in that league's history as well.
The organization had taken shape through two meetings in Canton, Ohio. The Pro Football Hall of Fame's historical chronology identifies three problems behind the attempt to organize: rising salaries, players moving between teams for higher offers, and teams employing players who remained enrolled in college. Representatives of Akron, Canton, Cleveland, and Dayton met in an automobile showroom on August 20, 1920. Their initial organization was called the American Professional Football Conference. Another gathering on September 17 expanded the enterprise and changed its name to the American Professional Football Association.
The September meeting took place in the Hupmobile showroom of Canton Bulldogs owner Ralph Hay, in the Odd Fellows Building. The Hall of Fame preserves its original minutes. Its account of the gathering identifies 11 represented franchises, including Akron and clubs from Illinois, Indiana, and New York. Massillon withdrew from professional football for the season and never joined the association. Jim Thorpe became the first president. The first game involving an association team was Rock Island's 48–0 victory over the St. Paul Ideals. A week later, Dayton defeated Columbus 14–0 in an encounter between two association members.
Order remained incomplete. According to the Hall's chronology, the association charged a membership fee of $100, which none of the teams paid. Clubs arranged their own schedules, producing considerable differences in total games and in the number against fellow association members. By early December, four clubs still had championship ambitions: Akron, Buffalo, Canton, and Decatur. Late-season encounters left Akron alone without a defeat. During one of those games, Akron sold tackle Bob Nash to Buffalo for $300 and five percent of the gate revenue, a transaction the chronology identifies as the association's first player deal.
The Hall's championship history places the Akron Pros at the beginning of a long period without an annual title game. It records that no official standings were maintained in the inaugural season, and dates the decision to award Akron the championship to the April 30 meeting. The league's first 13 seasons had no official championship game. A Chicago–Portsmouth playoff in 1932 counted in the regular standings; the annual championship-game arrangement began in 1933. In its first edition, Chicago defeated the New York Giants 23–21.
One of the champions' most important players was Fritz Pollard. His Hall of Fame biography records that he joined Akron in 1919 following Army service in World War I. When the team entered the association in 1920, Pollard was one of only two African American players in the new league. Contemporary accounts, as summarized by the Hall, described him as an especially feared running back. In 1921 the Akron Pros named him co-coach, making him the first African American head coach in league history. His subsequent professional career included other league clubs and independent teams. In 1928 he organized and coached the Chicago Black Hawks, an all-Black professional team whose winter exhibitions on the West Coast became especially successful.
A small gold object provides a more personal connection with the 1920 championship. In 2010, the Hall of Fame received a miniature football-shaped medallion, described as a fob, from the grandson of Akron tackle Karl Hilmer Johnson. The championship players had received fobs rather than rings. This example carried an inscription identifying its recipient, but its first initial was C instead of K. The donation also exposed a separate identification problem: the league's compiled historical roster associated the nickname Pike Johnson with a different man who had never played for Akron.
The museum's research staff consulted football historian David Neft while investigating the family account. Their resulting identification established Karl Hilmer Johnson as a Boston-born Army veteran who attended Washington and Lee University and played 22 league games for Akron during 1920 and 1921. The fob therefore connected a championship artifact with a corrected player record. The Hall already possessed other early championship fobs, but before this donation its oldest example had belonged to a member of the 1922 Canton Bulldogs. The Akron piece extended that part of the collection to the league's opening season.
On June 24, 1922, the association adopted the National Football League name. The Decatur club had moved to Chicago in 1921 and, in 1922, became the Bears. The Akron Pros' championship preceded both of those name changes.
- Pro Football Hall of Fame: Playoff Results: 1930s, including the 1920–1932 championship note — www.profootballhof.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame: Chronology of Football, 1869–1939, including 1920–1922 — www.profootballhof.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame: Sept. 17, 1920 — The Founding of the NFL — www.profootballhof.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame: Fritz Pollard biography — www.profootballhof.com
- Pro Football Hall of Fame: Medallion from NFL’s first champions — www.profootballhof.com