George Brett and the Pine Tar Home Run Dispute
On Sunday, July 24, 1983, in an afternoon game that Baseball-Reference lists as starting at 2:06 p.m. at Yankee Stadium, the Kansas City Royals trailed the New York Yankees 4-3 with two outs in the top of the ninth inning. George Brett, with U.L. Washington on first base, hit a home run off Yankees closer Goose Gossage that gave the Royals a 5-4 lead. The Hall of Fame's account of the game says that while Brett celebrated, Yankees manager Billy Martin walked to home plate and told umpire Tim McClelland that the bat was covered with more pine tar than the rules allowed.
Pine tar, the Hall of Fame explains, is a sticky glue-like substance used to give batters a better grip. McClelland carefully measured the bat against the 17-inch width of home plate, determined that it violated the 18-inch pine tar rule, turned to the Royals dugout and signaled that Brett was out. With two outs already on the board, that call ended the game. Brett charged McClelland, screaming, and teammates and Royals manager Dick Howser restrained him. The call stood, and the Royals filed a protest. The Hall of Fame notes that Brett, an All-Star third baseman, played his whole career, from 1973 to 1993, for Kansas City and led the American League in hits three times.
The protest put the decision in the hands of American League president Lee MacPhail. The Society for American Baseball Research says the league office was in charge of overseeing the umpiring staff, and that by the 1970s league presidents had little tangible power other than their ability to build consensus. MacPhail had been getting ready to leave the Yankees in 1973 when he was approached about succeeding the retiring Joe Cronin as American League president, and he held the post for ten years, and SABR calls the pine tar ruling the most famous of his presidency. He consulted his umpiring supervisors and members of the rules committee, then issued his ruling four days later. Baseball-Reference records the outcome in its box score of the game: it was protested by the visiting team and the protest was upheld.
MacPhail's reasoning went to the purpose of the rule rather than its measurement. SABR quotes him: "It was not a hard decision for me to make, for, in my opinion, the rule, the intent of the rule, and past precedents clearly indicated the umpires had erred." He believed that the motivation for the rule was not to keep hitters from gaining an unfair advantage, but to keep the baseballs clean. The punishment, therefore, did not fit the crime. MacPhail restored Brett's home run and ordered the game resumed with two outs in the top of the ninth, Kansas City ahead 5-4.
Baseball-Reference lists the game as suspended in the top of the ninth with the score 5-4 and completed on August 18, 1983. The original game drew 33,944 fans. The conclusion drew far fewer: the Hall of Fame puts the crowd on August 18 at about 1,200. SABR describes the date as an off day for both clubs, and says the game was concluded with four quick outs.
Martin protested again on August 18. The Hall of Fame says he put pitcher Ron Guidry in center field and moved left-handed first baseman Don Mattingly to second base as a symbolic gesture. Before the first pitch to Kansas City's Hal McRae, he protested that Brett had not touched all the bases on his home run and that the current umpiring crew could not verify it. Umpire Phillips produced an affidavit signed by the July 24 umpires stating that Brett had touched every base. Martin was ejected for arguing.
Then the game finished. The Hall of Fame says Yankees reliever George Frazier struck out McRae to end the top of the ninth, and Royals reliever Dan Quisenberry pitched a perfect bottom of the ninth to preserve Kansas City's 5-4 win. Baseball-Reference credits Mike Armstrong with the win, Gossage with the loss and Quisenberry with his 24th save.
The Yankees' owner did not accept the outcome quietly. SABR says George Steinbrenner publicly blasted the ruling, telling the press: "I wouldn't want to be Lee MacPhail living in New York. Maybe he should go house-hunting in Kansas City." On December 31, MacPhail's last official day as league president, Steinbrenner called him and asked him never to return to Yankee Stadium except on business.
The bat itself has a place in the museum. The Hall of Fame lists George Brett's pine tar bat from 1983 among the artifacts in its Whole New Ballgame exhibition on the museum's second floor.
- George Brett's pine tar home run — baseballhall.org
- SABR, Lee MacPhail — sabr.org
- Baseball-Reference, Kansas City Royals 5, New York Yankees 4, July 24, 1983 — www.baseball-reference.com
- National Baseball Hall of Fame, Bill Janetschek savors Whole New Ballgame opening — baseballhall.org