Jacques Plante: the fitted mask behind a midgame return
Jacques Plante left the ice with an injured face on November 1, 1959, and returned with protection already prepared for it. Andy Bathgate's shot had struck Montreal's goaltender during a game against the New York Rangers, cutting his nose and lip. HISTORY's account dates the start of his regular NHL mask use to that return. An NHL account names the mask's maker as Bill Burchmore.
The mask was a fitted object with a manufacturing history. HISTORY describes a Montreal hospital taking a close plaster impression of Jacques Plante's face and passing it to specialists who constructed a fiberglass covering. Earlier game injuries had fractured his cheekbones, giving him a reason to commission protection before that November night. He had already tried the mask in practices and exhibitions. A shape prepared from his own features therefore existed before Bathgate's shot forced the decision during a regular-season game. The material work and preliminary trials preceded the midgame return.
Montreal won 3-1. In the later HISTORY summary, coach Toe Blake anticipated better masks and their eventual adoption as ordinary goalie equipment. The same summary describes an earlier obstacle: Clint Benedict of the Montreal Maroons had covered his nose and part of his face in 1930, then abandoned the protection because it interfered with his view of low shots. A covering that kept an injured face safer could still create a playing problem. The relevant test included seeing the puck near the ice, alongside surviving its impact.
The visual record preserves the difference between the unprotected job and the new equipment. A photograph discussed by Sports Illustrated in 2012 shows Jacques Plante crouching to locate the puck in a 1957 game against the Rangers. The earlier photograph was also a Sports Illustrated cover image. Hackel was discussing a selection of 100 sports photographs that included five hockey images. The 1957 Plante cover photograph ranked 60th in that selection. Another, identified as taken after the November 1, 1959 game, records the aftermath of Bathgate's shot. Stu Hackel identifies the shot as a backhander and describes Plante refusing to return after treatment unless Blake allowed the mask. The earlier action image also places dressed-up spectators close behind the play; the later photograph follows an injury that made the availability of protection an immediate condition of playing.
Resistance went beyond the fit of the covering. Steve Rushin's 2020 Sports Illustrated retrospective collects objections from other hockey figures. Rangers goalie Gump Worsley feared losing sight of pucks at his feet. New York general manager Muzz Patrick objected to concealing the player's face from spectators. Glenn Hall remembered initially considering Plante timid for wearing protection. These were objections about visibility, public presentation and toughness, assembled in a later retrospective. Blake also had an immediate personnel problem. With NHL clubs carrying one goalie, refusing Plante's condition meant turning to the Rangers' available house goalie.
Boston's Don Simmons tried a mask within weeks of Plante's return. Rushin also describes college coaches having their goalies fitted with molded fiberglass protection. Hall eventually wore a mask with St. Louis in 1968, sharing goaltending duties with Plante. Worsley held out much longer, using protection for his final six NHL games in 1974. Adoption consequently involved individual decisions spread across seasons. Jacques Plante's return against the Rangers supplied a conspicuous example, but the later conversions show that fellow goalies did not all accept the equipment together or for identical reasons.
A later primary document makes the engineering tradeoffs unusually explicit. Dale R. Kasper's US patent 3,897,597, published in 1975, describes a face-and-head protector for activities including hockey. Its discussion of existing equipment identifies restricted vision, uncomfortable heat, fogging and unstable harnesses as design problems. The proposed construction combines a helmet with a transparent face shield attached at several points. Ventilation openings or spaced ribs allow air circulation, while an adjustable chin strap positions the assembly. These are the inventor's stated aims for a later design, separate from the fiberglass mask used in 1959.
Kasper also described keeping the shield a short distance from the face and extending protection around the cheeks. Its claims specify a U-shaped shield wrapping around the face. The description aligns helmet openings with air channels between strips of interior padding. His drawings make fit, coverage and airflow parts of the same apparatus. The listed advantages are the inventor's proposed results, rather than measured outcomes from NHL games. The construction nevertheless gives those aims a physical form: multiple attachment points, space around the face and routes for circulating air. Protection had to remain in position while allowing the wearer to see and breathe.
- NHL, Nov. 1: Plante debuts mask in NHL game: 1959 injury, masked return and 3-1 result — www.nhl.com
- HISTORY, Montreal’s Jacques Plante becomes first NHL goaltender to wear facemask: construction and game result — www.history.com
- Stu Hackel, Sports Illustrated, Hockey’s the most photogenic of sports: 1957 and November 1, 1959 photographs — www.si.com
- Steve Rushin, Sports Illustrated, Don’t Worry, It’s Just a Face, September 16, 2020: later recollections of mask resistance — www.si.com
- Dale R. Kasper, US3897597A, Face and head protector, August 5, 1975: description and drawings, Google Patents — patents.google.com
- Dave Stubbs, NHL, Plante mask mold finds way to Hockey Hall of Fame, March 3, 2019: Bill Burchmore and mask construction — www.nhl.com