The seventh-inning stretch in a letter, a photograph and a song cover
The seventh-inning stretch has a history older than the familiar tale of President William Howard Taft rising from his seat in 1910. A passage attributed to Cincinnati Red Stockings manager Harry Wright in an 1869 letter describes spectators standing between halves of the seventh, moving their limbs and sometimes walking around. The United States Postal Service reproduced that passage in its 2008 Postal Bulletin. The description concerns an existing crowd habit, giving no named inventor and no date when the spectators first began doing it.
The distinction between the letter and its later reproduction matters. The Postal Bulletin supplies a quotation attributed to Wright; it does not display his manuscript or identify its recipient. Its explanation connects the spectators' movement with relief from sitting on hard benches. That is a narrower proposition than establishing an uninterrupted tradition at every ballpark from 1869 onward. The seventh-inning stretch could be described before Taft's presidency without the surviving reference identifying one moment of creation.
Taft's participation in another ballpark ritual has a clearer photographic record. The White House Historical Association reproduces a Library of Congress photograph captioned as the president throwing the first pitch on opening day at National Stadium in 1910. The photograph documents that ceremonial act. Its subject is a presidential throw, rather than the birth of the seventh-inning stretch. A dated image of one ceremony cannot, by itself, establish the origin of a different action later in the game.
Stephen V. Rice's reconstruction for the Society for American Baseball Research places that opening day in Washington on April 14, 1910, against Philadelphia. Rice identifies his contemporary sources as the April 15 Washington Post and Washington Herald and the April 23 Sporting Life. Umpire Billy Evans brought Taft a baseball, which the president threw to Washington pitcher Walter Johnson. The large crowd required spectators to occupy areas near the outfield fences as well as the seats. Those arrangements even affected the ground rules for batted balls. Catcher Gabby Street put the ceremonial ball aside for safekeeping.
The seventh inning had its own event on the field. With Johnson still pitching a no-hitter, Frank Baker hit a deep fly; right fielder Doc Gessler collided with a spectator and the ball fell for a double. Washington eventually won 3-0, and Taft stayed through the finish. Those details place the presidential appearance inside a documented game. They do not identify a new seventh-inning stretch. The celebrated first pitch and the later origin tale involve the same president but require different supporting evidence.
An object from that year complicates the vocabulary, too. The Library of Congress catalogue Baseball's Greatest Hits describes Edward Clark's 1910 sheet music My Old Man Is Baseball Mad, published by Harry Von Tilzer. Charles Arthur Etherington illustrated its cover with an insect-like figure made from bats, wearing catching equipment and having a baseball for a head. Across the top appears the banner “All Stretch – Seventh Inning.” The catalogue supplies a copyright registration number, E230831, tying the description to an identifiable published object. A manuscript version is catalogued separately under E230409, distinguishing the published edition from the handwritten music.
The catalogue calls the cover an early printed appearance of the expression and places its publication soon after the April 1910 presidential game. That physical wording cannot be reconciled with the Postal Bulletin's separate assertion that the term cannot be traced earlier than 1920. The dated music cover supports a more cautious chronology for the seventh-inning stretch: descriptions of standing, later explanations of its origin and printed names for the custom need not begin at the same time. The cover establishes usage, without settling who first stood up.
The music now associated with the pause had another beginning. Amy Whorf McGuiggan's National Recording Registry notes trace Take Me Out to the Ball Game to lyrics by Jack Norworth and music by Albert von Tilzer, copyrighted in 1908. Its original verses concern Katie Casey asking her companion to take her to baseball. Edward Meeker recorded it on an Edison cylinder that September. A commercially published song and recording therefore preceded their familiar place inside the stadium routine.
McGuiggan also describes the later partnership of White Sox broadcaster Harry Caray and owner Bill Veeck in making the singing public in 1976. She distinguishes the often-repeated secret-microphone tale from recollections by Mike Veeck and Skip Caray that Caray was persuaded to participate. The song's route into the seventh-inning stretch thus has its own witnesses and competing recollections. Wright's attributed letter, Taft's photograph, the 1910 cover and the early recording mark different stages of a custom assembled over time, rather than one presidential gesture creating the whole ritual.
- United States Postal Service, Postal Bulletin 22235, Origin of the 7th Inning Stretch, 2008; reproduces the attributed 1869 Harry Wright letter — about.usps.com
- White House Historical Association, President Taft Throws the First Pitch: Library of Congress photograph, 1910 — www.whitehousehistory.org
- Stephen V. Rice, SABR, April 14, 1910: Walter Johnson impresses President Taft on Opening Day — sabr.org
- Susan Clermont and Katherine Walden, Library of Congress, Baseball's Greatest Hits, third revised edition, pp. 125–126: Edward Clark's 1910 sheet music — www.loc.gov
- Amy Whorf McGuiggan, Library of Congress National Recording Registry, Take Me Out to the Ball Game: Edward Meeker, 1908 — www.loc.gov